I've been spending increasingly more time in Brooklyn these days. I realize the more time I spend there, the less likely I am to reach one of my top ten New York goals: to attend a party at The Dakota. Anyway, last weekend Shaun was in town for the Go! Team concert, which by the way was stellar. Before the show we met up with Aaron at Galapagos in Williamsburg for 'Opera and Beer'- 5 female opera singers performing with a keyboard in various operatic European languages. It was a perfect day of perfect activities for a dialectical sensibility. Galapagos is a gorgeous art space/bar-of course one of dozens in New York. True to the scale and form of Brooklyn, it occupies a rough industrial space, but possesses a glass like reflecting pool of water at the entrance which one has to pass over on a metal gangway upon entering. From inside the bar looking out, the water creates a stunning reflection of the concrete plant across the street.
(from Galapogos website)
(photo from Shaun Smakal)
Each time I'm in Williamsburg I can't help but muse over it's shocking similitude to Omaha; the scale, the industrial desolation that teems with artists, the thrift store meets Prada inspired fashion, the restaurants, the PBR on tap, and especially.....the hipsters. I've always perceived these similarities, but not until this recent rendezvous did I realize their depth. The breed of hipster that has colonized Williamsburg in the last 5 years have derived from the hellmouth of hipsterdom: Omaha's Saddle Creek Records. I witnessed the birth of this movement in the early/mid 90's when I would help my friend Jen sneak the would be Bright Eyes lead singer into our female only college accommodations. He was 13 and she swore to us this greasy haired, acne faced, pre-pubescent boy was going to be something big. Now consider the effect Saddle Creek has had on our nations music scene.
As Shaun and I wandered the streets of Williamsburg in between events, I realized another unforeseen outcome of that greasy haired 13-year old kid who feverishly recorded songs on 8-track in his laundry room during repeated month long snow blizzards in Omaha. It may be a stretch to suggest that Conor Oberst is responsible for the myriads of yuppie condo developments sprouting up all over Williamsburg, but it is an unavoidable, as well as intriguing connection. It is a connection that solidifies the fact that one's passions and hard work can contribute to an ideological trajectory opposed to the original intent. These are the guts of gentrification, and a very typical story in the development of American urbanity. Culture and urban form are intimate bedfellows.




Even more intriguing is the disparate connection between a group of musicians/artists who are the bastions of independence - they have self produced every album as a collective, have resisted multi-million dollar record deals with every imaginable record company, continue to reside in Omaha in their original neighborhoods and support the local arts scene - with that of the notion of developer driven condos. Condo living may infact be a contemporary typology representative of mass-mindedness.
Images are from various developer website. Yes, I'm getting sloppy with the pilfering.

9 comments:
I was thinking... Aren't there condo towers going up in every part of New York? Including Harlem. Or most any city in North America? And China? And everywhere else? It certainly is a symbol of mass-something-or-other.
So I'm not sure that the Saddle Creek scene is the genesis for 'Condos in Brooklyn' [you should pass along that title as the genesis for a new song or two, though just in case] or why the culture sprung up there in the first place. Sure the place is chock full of the bloody things [hipsters, I mean] but I think we'd be too specific to narrow the issue of genetrification to those adorable, scarf-wearing, girlie-but-androgenous folk of questionable hygene and all genders. But it's also been drawing others for longer, I think. Young families who can't afford Manhattan, for one. The artists and creatives who got pushed out Manhattan decades ago...
I'll admit I'm far too ignorant of culture driven development--living and growing up in the world's capital of Fordist industrial/economic driven urbanity, as I am--to be anything other than cautious. I know they make for diverse, vibrant and interesting places to live and it's unfortunate to see that obliterated by McBLT's...
[BLT=Big Lofty Tower]
Yes, you are correct, this stuff is being built everywhere. But Williamsburg definitely seems to have the largest mass of hip condo complexes in part due to how fast it's gentrified by the hipsters.
My post never mentioned Brooklyn in general - it's too large and diverse of a borough, but rather focused on Williamsburg. The hipster scene that looks and smells like Saddle Creek doesn't much extend beyond Williamsburg, as far as I can tell.
Ahhhhh!!!! So the HIPSTERS are doing the gentrifying... Okay, I completely missed that notion. My bad. In that context, I sound like a total retard!
So yeah... It certianly doesn't probe very far into the Hasidic part of Brooklyn! All those triple wide baby strollers must get in the way!
The Hasidic part is also Williamsburg, actually.
The next time I listen to "Cassadaga", I'm going to be keeping my ears open for hidden references to a college-age AT. I'm also going to thinking of excuse to mention partying with Win Butler and the rest of the Arcade Fire last month in Seattle, to counter your story of hanging with Conor Oberst way back when, without coming across like just another name dropper. Oh, whoops, look what I just did.
You can't think of condos without thinking of downtown Vancouver, AT - the way Concorde Pacific Place wraps around Yaletown; the new Woodwards right next to Gastown (which I know you know way too much about). Who can afford to live in Yaletown? No one I know. Soon the same will be true for Gastown. I'm not sure what the connection is, but I suspect it has *something* to do with proximity. The same thing is happening to Main Street (including the hilarious "Get Ready For The Hippest Condos Ever" development on the corner of Main & 12th - the actual slogan - built literally on the ashes of heritage houses that were burnt down by hundreds of punks one night a couple of years ago before the city could demolish them - talk about a housewrecker - the highest rated party ever @ www.partyarmy.ca - Chief Warrant Officer Johnny B was there). At this rate, the practically unredevelopable West End, in all its old fashionedness, may be literally left standing as the last authentic neighbourhood-as-community downtown.
nice comments, JB. I must say that since I've met you - way back when - your knowledge of and intuition about all things urban form has become truly inspiring. And the fact that you were at the punk house party?? I remember the night that happened. I was living on Main Street - 2003? My classmates thought I was nuts to be living on Main Street and not in Kitsilano.
Nice name drop. Hey, no shame in a fascination with these things. People and their journey's are fascinating.
BTW JB, your comment actually tweaked a twinge of longing for Vancouver and all it's absurdity. The images in my head as I was reading your comment were like a real-time tour. Thanks. That was fun. Maybe I'm finally coming to some peace with Vancouver!!!!!!!!!!
Actually, his comments made me want to go burn down Gastown and save everyone the trouble...
There was a wonderfully ironic inclusion of a West Vancouver split-level house remodeled by Cardew in the latest 'suburban'-oriented issue of dwell. The whole time I kept thinking, They would have served their audience better and engaged in some meaningful discussion on the embrace of suburbanism in contemporary society if they'd chosen something downtown.
Post a Comment